MH State Board All Notes Free5th to 12th & BA, BSc, B.Com 🔍

Mutual Fund Foundations CBCFB6T10

RTMNU B.Com Semester 6 · Major: Finance and Banking · 4 units · notes for every unit

UniversityRTMNU – Rashtrasant Tukadoji Maharaj Nagpur University, Nagpur
CourseB.Com (Four Year UG Programme, NEP 2020)
SemesterSemester VI
Paper codeCBCFB6T10
Paper titleMutual Fund Foundations
CategoryMajor: Finance and Banking
Credits4 credits
Marks80 marks theory paper (3 hours)
Syllabusas per official RTMNU NEP 2020 B.Com syllabus for Sem V & VI (session 2026-27 onwards)

Unit topics below follow the official RTMNU syllabus. RTMNU official website · All RTMNU B.Com papers

Units

  1. 1Unit I: Introduction to Mutual FundsNotes
  2. 2Unit II: Regulatory Framework and Investor ProtectionNotes
  3. 3Unit III: Types of Mutual Fund SchemesNotes
  4. 4Unit IV: Net Asset Value (NAV) and Performance EvaluationNotes

RTMNU B.Com Sem 6 · CBCFB6T10 · Unit I

Unit I: Introduction to Mutual Funds

Syllabus topics (RTMNU)

  • Meaning, Concept and Evolution of Mutual Funds
  • Growth of the Mutual Fund Industry in India
  • Structure of Mutual Funds in India: Sponsor, Trustee, Asset Management Company (AMC), Custodian
  • Advantages and Limitations of Mutual Funds
  • Investment in Mutual Funds: Lump-sum Investment, Systematic Investment Plan (SIP), Systematic Withdrawal Plan (SWP)

Meaning and Concept of Mutual Funds

Definition: A mutual fund is a trust that collects money from many investors with a common investment goal and invests it in shares, bonds, money market instruments and other securities. The income and gains are shared by the investors in proportion to the units they hold.

In simple words, a mutual fund is a common pool of money. An investor buys units of the fund. The value of one unit is called the Net Asset Value (NAV). Professional fund managers decide where the money is invested.

Key features:

  1. Pooling of funds: small savings of many people are put together into a large fund.
  2. Professional management: trained fund managers and research teams manage the money.
  3. Diversification: money is spread over many securities, so risk is reduced.
  4. Units and NAV: investors own units; unit value moves with the market value of the portfolio.
  5. Regulated: in India every mutual fund must be registered with SEBI.
  6. Market-linked returns: returns are not guaranteed; they depend on the market.
Remember: A mutual fund is set up as a trust under the Indian Trusts Act, 1882. The money belongs to the unit holders, not to the company that manages it.

Evolution and Growth of the Mutual Fund Industry in India

The Indian industry is usually studied in four phases:

PhasePeriodMain events
Phase I1963–1987Unit Trust of India (UTI) set up in 1963 by an Act of Parliament under RBI. Its first scheme, Unit Scheme 1964 (US-64), was very popular. UTI was the only mutual fund.
Phase II1987–1993Public sector banks and insurers allowed to start funds. SBI Mutual Fund (1987) was the first non-UTI fund; LIC and GIC funds followed.
Phase III1993–2003Private and foreign players allowed. First SEBI regulations in 1993 (Kothari Pioneer was the first private fund). Comprehensive SEBI (Mutual Funds) Regulations, 1996 framed.
Phase IV2003 onwardsUTI split in 2003 (UTI Mutual Fund came under SEBI rules). Consolidation, growth of SIPs, online investing, ETFs and index funds, and SEBI's scheme categorisation (2017).

Reasons for growth in India: rising incomes and savings; awareness campaigns such as "Mutual Funds Sahi Hai" by AMFI; easy online and app-based investing; small SIPs from ₹500 (even less in some schemes); tax benefits under ELSS; strong regulation by SEBI; and growth in smaller towns (B-30 cities). Industry assets (AUM) and monthly SIP inflows have grown many times in the last ten years — check the latest AMFI monthly data for current figures.

Structure of Mutual Funds in India

Indian mutual funds have a three-tier structure: Sponsor → Trust (Trustees) → AMC, supported by a Custodian and other service providers.

  1. Sponsor: the person or company that sets up the mutual fund, like a promoter of a company (e.g. SBI for SBI Mutual Fund, ICICI Bank and Prudential for ICICI Prudential MF). The sponsor creates the trust, appoints trustees, sets up the AMC and contributes to the AMC's net worth. It must have a sound track record and be approved by SEBI.
  2. Trustee (Board of Trustees or Trustee Company): holds the property of the fund in trust for unit holders. Trustees protect investors' interest, supervise the AMC, check that schemes follow SEBI rules and the trust deed, and report to SEBI. At least two-thirds of the trustees must be independent of the sponsor.
  3. Asset Management Company (AMC): the company that actually manages the money — launches schemes, invests funds, does research, calculates and publishes NAV, and markets the schemes. It earns a management fee. It must have a minimum net worth fixed by SEBI and at least half of its board must be independent directors.
  4. Custodian: a SEBI-registered entity (usually a bank) that keeps the securities of the fund in safe custody, settles purchases and sales, and collects dividends and interest. It should be independent of the sponsor.
  5. Other agencies: Registrar and Transfer Agent (RTA, e.g. CAMS, KFintech) keeps investor records and processes applications; auditors; distributors (AMFI-registered, with ARN).
Diagram to draw: a box "Sponsor" at top → arrow to "Trustees (Mutual Fund Trust)" → arrow to "AMC" → arrows from AMC to "Custodian", "RTA", "Distributors" and "Investors (unit holders)".

Advantages of Mutual Funds

  1. Professional management at low cost.
  2. Diversification even with small money.
  3. Liquidity: open-ended units can be redeemed any business day at NAV.
  4. Small investment: SIP from a few hundred rupees.
  5. Transparency: daily NAV, monthly portfolio and factsheets.
  6. Choice: equity, debt, hybrid, index, gold, sectoral and other schemes.
  7. Safety of structure: SEBI regulation, trustees and custodian protect the money.
  8. Tax benefit: ELSS gives deduction under the old regime (check latest tax rules).

Limitations of Mutual Funds

  1. No guaranteed return: market risk stays.
  2. Costs: expense ratio and exit load reduce returns.
  3. No control: investor cannot choose individual shares.
  4. Too many schemes: confusing for a new investor.
  5. Fund manager risk: poor decisions affect returns.
  6. Over-diversification can dilute gains.

Investment in Mutual Funds: Lump-sum, SIP and SWP

1. Lump-sum investment: the whole amount is invested at one time, e.g. ₹1,00,000 invested in one go. Suitable when the investor has a large sum (bonus, sale of property) and the market is reasonably priced. Risk: wrong timing.

2. Systematic Investment Plan (SIP): a fixed amount is invested at regular intervals (usually monthly) by auto-debit, e.g. ₹2,000 on the 5th of every month. Benefits:

  • Rupee cost averaging: more units are bought when NAV is low and fewer when NAV is high, so the average cost per unit is lowered.
  • Power of compounding over long periods.
  • Discipline — saving becomes a habit; no need to time the market.

3. Systematic Withdrawal Plan (SWP): the investor withdraws a fixed amount at regular intervals from an existing investment, e.g. a retired person withdrawing ₹15,000 every month from a hybrid fund. It gives regular income while the balance stays invested. (Related: STP — Systematic Transfer Plan — moves a fixed amount from one scheme to another of the same fund house.)

BasisLump-sumSIPSWP
Flow of moneyOne-time inflowRegular inflowRegular outflow
Suitable forLarge idle sumSalaried, small saversRetired, need regular income
Timing riskHighLow (averaging)Depends on market at withdrawal
Exam tip: For a 16-mark question on "structure of mutual funds", draw the diagram and explain each constituent with its functions; end with a line on how this structure protects investors.

Likely exam questions

  1. (Long, 8/16 marks) Explain the meaning of mutual funds and trace the evolution and growth of the mutual fund industry in India.
  2. (Long, 8/16 marks) Describe the structure of mutual funds in India with the role of sponsor, trustee, AMC and custodian. Also state the advantages and limitations of mutual funds.
  3. (Short, 4 marks) Define mutual fund and state its features.
  4. (Short, 4 marks) What is a Systematic Investment Plan (SIP)? State its benefits.
  5. (Short, 4 marks) Distinguish between SIP and SWP.

RTMNU B.Com Sem 6 · CBCFB6T10 · Unit II

Unit II: Regulatory Framework and Investor Protection

Syllabus topics (RTMNU)

  • Role of Securities and Exchange Board of India
  • Legal Framework: SEBI (Mutual Funds) Regulations
  • Association of Mutual Funds in India (AMFI): Role and Functions
  • Risk Management Practices
  • Investor Protection Measures
  • Grievance Redressal Mechanism (SCORES platform of SEBI)
  • Ethical Issues in Mutual Fund Distribution

Role of Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI)

SEBI is the statutory regulator of the Indian securities market, set up in 1988 and given legal powers by the SEBI Act, 1992. Every mutual fund in India must register with SEBI before collecting money from the public.

Role of SEBI in the mutual fund industry:

  1. Registration: grants a certificate of registration to a mutual fund after checking the sponsor's track record and net worth.
  2. Rule making: frames and updates the SEBI (Mutual Funds) Regulations and issues circulars (e.g. a master circular for mutual funds).
  3. Approval of schemes: checks the Scheme Information Document (SID) before a New Fund Offer (NFO).
  4. Categorisation: in 2017 SEBI fixed standard categories of schemes so that each fund house has only one scheme per category (with few exceptions).
  5. Investor protection: rules on disclosure, riskometer, expense limits, valuation and fair treatment.
  6. Inspection and penalties: inspects AMCs and trustees and can impose penalties or cancel registration.
  7. Grievance redressal through SCORES and online dispute resolution.

These Regulations are the main law for mutual funds in India. Important provisions:

  1. Constitution as a trust: a mutual fund must be formed as a trust; the trust deed must be registered.
  2. Eligibility of sponsor: sound track record, profits and positive net worth; the sponsor must contribute a minimum share of the AMC's net worth.
  3. Trustees: at least two-thirds of trustees must be independent; they must supervise the AMC and send reports to SEBI.
  4. AMC: must have the minimum net worth prescribed by SEBI, at least 50% independent directors, and cannot do business that conflicts with fund management.
  5. Schemes: offer documents (SID, SAI, KIM) must be filed; NFO cannot stay open beyond the time allowed.
  6. Investment restrictions: limits on how much a scheme can invest in a single company, sector or group, to ensure diversification.
  7. Valuation and NAV: NAV of open-ended schemes must be calculated and published every business day.
  8. Disclosures: half-yearly results, annual report, monthly portfolio, factsheet.
  9. Expenses: limits on the Total Expense Ratio (TER) charged to the scheme.
Remember: The SEBI limits (AMC net worth, TER slabs, disclosure deadlines) are revised from time to time — check the latest SEBI master circular before quoting any number.

Association of Mutual Funds in India (AMFI): Role and Functions

AMFI is the industry body of all SEBI-registered AMCs in India, set up in 1995 as a non-profit organisation. It is not a regulator, but SEBI has given it important responsibilities.

  1. Code of ethics: lays down ethical standards for AMCs and distributors.
  2. Distributor registration: gives the AMFI Registration Number (ARN) to distributors who pass the NISM certification exam.
  3. Investor awareness: runs campaigns such as "Mutual Funds Sahi Hai".
  4. Data publication: publishes daily NAVs of all schemes and monthly industry data (AUM, SIP flows).
  5. Representation: represents the industry to SEBI, RBI and the Government.
  6. Best practices and standards: issues guidelines on uniform practices.

Risk Management Practices

Mutual funds face market risk, credit risk (default by bond issuer), interest-rate risk, liquidity risk and operational risk. Main practices:

  • Diversification and SEBI investment limits per issuer and sector.
  • Riskometer: every scheme shows its risk on a six-level scale — Low, Low to Moderate, Moderate, Moderately High, High and Very High — reviewed monthly.
  • Credit research and use of credit ratings for debt papers.
  • Liquidity management: keeping liquid assets, stress testing of debt and liquid schemes.
  • Risk Management Committee and a Chief Risk Officer at the AMC.
  • Fair valuation of securities and segregation of a bad debt paper into a separate portfolio ("side pocketing") when allowed.

Investor Protection Measures

  1. Money held in trust; securities with an independent custodian.
  2. Full disclosure in SID/KIM before investing; daily NAV.
  3. KYC (Know Your Customer) norms for all investors.
  4. Entry load abolished by SEBI (2009), so the full amount is invested.
  5. Direct plans with lower expense ratio available.
  6. Consolidated Account Statement (CAS) showing all holdings.
  7. Nomination facility; time limits for paying redemption money.
  8. Unit holders' consent/exit option before any change in fundamental attributes of a scheme.

Grievance Redressal Mechanism (SCORES Platform of SEBI)

Steps:

  1. Complaint first to the AMC/RTA (investor relations officer).
  2. If not solved, file on SCORES (SEBI Complaints Redress System), SEBI's online platform launched in 2011 (an upgraded SCORES 2.0 was introduced later). The complaint goes to the AMC, which must reply within the time set by SEBI; it can be escalated within SEBI if the investor is not satisfied.
  3. Unresolved disputes can go to SEBI's Online Dispute Resolution (ODR) portal for conciliation and arbitration.

Advantages of SCORES: 24×7 online access, tracking by complaint number, no paperwork, and time-bound replies. Check the latest SEBI timelines.

Ethical Issues in Mutual Fund Distribution

  • Mis-selling: selling a high-risk scheme to a risk-averse person, or promising "guaranteed returns".
  • Churning: making investors switch schemes often to earn commission.
  • Hiding costs or not explaining exit loads and risk.
  • Conflict of interest: pushing schemes that pay higher commission.
  • Misuse of investor data or signing forms on investors' behalf.

Remedies: AMFI code of conduct, suitability checks, disclosure of commission, SEBI's separation of distribution and advisory (Investment Advisers Regulations), and penalties/ARN cancellation.

Exam tip: In a question on SEBI's role, write 8–10 points with headings; add one line each on SCORES and the riskometer to show current knowledge.

Likely exam questions

  1. (Long, 8/16 marks) Explain the role of SEBI in regulating mutual funds and state the main provisions of the SEBI (Mutual Funds) Regulations.
  2. (Long, 8/16 marks) Discuss the investor protection measures and the grievance redressal mechanism (SCORES) available to mutual fund investors in India.
  3. (Short, 4 marks) State the role and functions of AMFI.
  4. (Short, 4 marks) What is a riskometer?
  5. (Short, 4 marks) Explain any four ethical issues in mutual fund distribution.

RTMNU B.Com Sem 6 · CBCFB6T10 · Unit III

Unit III: Types of Mutual Fund Schemes

Syllabus topics (RTMNU)

  • Classification based on Structure: Open-ended, Closed-ended, Interval Funds
  • Classification based on Investment Objective: Equity Funds, Debt Funds, Hybrid Funds, Money Market Funds
  • Thematic and Sectoral Funds
  • Index Funds and Exchange Traded Funds (ETFs)
  • Solution-Oriented Schemes (Retirement & Children's Funds)

Classification based on Structure: Open-ended, Closed-ended and Interval Funds

1. Open-ended fund: a scheme that is open for purchase and redemption on every business day at NAV-based prices. It has no fixed maturity and no fixed number of units — units are created when people buy and cancelled when they redeem. Most Indian schemes are open-ended (e.g. an equity large-cap fund).

2. Closed-ended fund: a scheme with a fixed maturity (e.g. 3 years). Units are sold only during the New Fund Offer (NFO). After that, investors cannot buy from or sell back to the fund until maturity; to give an exit, units must be listed on a stock exchange, where they may trade at a discount or premium to NAV. Examples: Fixed Maturity Plans (FMPs).

3. Interval fund: a mix of the two. It is mainly closed but opens for purchase/redemption during specified transaction periods at fixed intervals (e.g. every quarter). Units are also listed.

BasisOpen-endedClosed-endedInterval
MaturityNoneFixedFixed/periodic windows
Entry/exit with fundAny business dayOnly at NFO and maturityDuring set intervals
Unit capitalKeeps changingFixedChanges at intervals
ListingNot neededCompulsoryCompulsory
LiquidityHighestLow (exchange only)Moderate

Classification based on Investment Objective

SEBI's categorisation (2017) groups schemes into equity, debt, hybrid, solution-oriented and other schemes, with defined categories inside each.

1. Equity funds invest mainly in shares; objective is long-term capital growth; risk high. Main SEBI categories:

  • Large-cap (top 100 companies by market value), mid-cap (101st–250th), small-cap (251st onwards), large & mid-cap, multi-cap, flexi-cap.
  • ELSS (Equity Linked Savings Scheme): 3-year lock-in; tax deduction under the old regime — check latest tax rules.
  • Dividend yield, value/contra, focused (limited number of stocks) funds.

2. Debt funds invest in fixed-income instruments — government securities, corporate bonds, treasury bills, commercial paper. Objective: regular income with lower risk than equity. Categories are mainly by maturity/duration (overnight, liquid, ultra-short, short, medium, long duration) and by credit (corporate bond fund, credit risk fund, banking & PSU fund, gilt fund). Risks: interest-rate risk and credit risk.

3. Hybrid funds invest in both equity and debt to balance growth and stability: conservative hybrid (mostly debt), balanced/aggressive hybrid (mostly equity), dynamic asset allocation (balanced advantage), multi-asset allocation (three asset classes), arbitrage funds and equity savings funds.

4. Money market funds invest in short-term money market instruments maturing up to one year — treasury bills, commercial paper, certificates of deposit, TREPS. They are very liquid and low risk; used by companies and individuals to park short-term surplus. (Liquid funds are a close type, with maturity up to 91 days.)

BasisEquity fundDebt fundHybrid fund
Invests inSharesBonds, money marketBoth
ObjectiveGrowthIncome, stabilityBalance
RiskHighLow to moderateModerate
Ideal horizon5+ yearsDays to few years3+ years

Thematic and Sectoral Funds

Sectoral fund: invests mainly in one sector, e.g. banking, IT, pharma. Thematic fund: invests in a broad theme cutting across sectors, e.g. infrastructure, consumption, ESG, manufacturing. SEBI requires a high minimum share of assets in the chosen sector/theme (check the latest SEBI category rules).

  • Merits: high returns when the sector does well; good for informed investors.
  • Demerits: concentration risk — less diversification; returns are cyclical; need timing.

Index Funds and Exchange Traded Funds (ETFs)

Index fund: a passively managed fund that copies a market index (e.g. Nifty 50, Sensex) by holding the same shares in the same proportion. Its aim is to match, not beat, the index. Benefits: low expense ratio, no fund-manager bias, transparency. The gap between fund and index return is called tracking error.

ETF: also tracks an index or a commodity (e.g. Nifty 50 ETF, Gold ETF), but its units are listed and traded on the stock exchange like shares throughout the day. A demat and trading account is needed.

BasisIndex fundETF
Buying/sellingFrom AMC at day-end NAVOn exchange at live market price
Demat accountNot neededNeeded
SIPEasyPossible through broker
CostLowUsually lower, plus brokerage

Solution-Oriented Schemes (Retirement and Children's Funds)

These are SEBI categories designed for a specific life goal, with a lock-in of at least 5 years or till the goal (retirement age / child attaining majority), whichever is earlier.

  • Retirement fund: builds a corpus for old age; may move from equity to debt as retirement nears; SWP can give pension-like income.
  • Children's fund: saves for a child's education or marriage.

Merits: goal-based discipline, long-term compounding, lock-in prevents early withdrawal. Demerit: lower liquidity.

Exam tip: For "types of mutual funds", draw a classification chart — by structure, by objective (equity/debt/hybrid/money market), and special types (sectoral, index, ETF, solution-oriented) — then explain each with an Indian example.

Likely exam questions

  1. (Long, 8/16 marks) Classify mutual fund schemes on the basis of structure and investment objective. Explain each type briefly.
  2. (Long, 8/16 marks) What are index funds and Exchange Traded Funds? Distinguish between them and explain thematic, sectoral and solution-oriented schemes.
  3. (Short, 4 marks) Distinguish between open-ended and closed-ended funds.
  4. (Short, 4 marks) What is an interval fund?
  5. (Short, 4 marks) What are money market funds?

RTMNU B.Com Sem 6 · CBCFB6T10 · Unit IV

Unit IV: Net Asset Value (NAV) and Performance Evaluation

Syllabus topics (RTMNU)

  • Concept and Calculation of NAV (Including Simple Practical Problems)
  • Expense Ratio and Loads
  • Risk–Return Analysis
  • Performance Measurement Tools: Concept and Simple Practical Problems on Sharpe Ratio, Treynor Ratio, Jensen's Alpha
  • Benchmarking of Mutual Funds
  • Portfolio Disclosure Norms

Concept and Calculation of NAV

Definition: Net Asset Value (NAV) is the market value of one unit of a mutual fund scheme, found by dividing the net assets of the scheme by the number of units outstanding.

Formula: NAV per unit = (Market value of investments + Cash & bank + Receivables + Accrued income + Other assets − Liabilities − Accrued expenses) ÷ Number of units outstanding

Points to remember: NAV of open-ended schemes is declared every business day; investors buy and redeem at NAV (less exit load, if any); a higher NAV does not mean a costlier or better fund — what matters is the rate of change of NAV.

Illustration 1: From the following details of Swaraj Equity Fund on 31 March, calculate NAV per unit. Equity shares at market value ₹480 lakh; debentures at market value ₹120 lakh; cash and bank ₹15 lakh; accrued interest ₹3 lakh; other receivables ₹2 lakh; accrued expenses ₹4 lakh; amount payable for securities purchased ₹6 lakh; units outstanding 40 lakh (face value ₹10).

Particulars₹ lakh
Equity shares (market value)480
Debentures (market value)120
Cash and bank15
Accrued interest3
Other receivables2
Total assets620
Less: Accrued expenses(4)
Less: Payable for securities purchased(6)
Net assets610

NAV per unit = ₹610 lakh ÷ 40 lakh units = ₹15.25.

Illustration 2 (return from NAV): NAV at the beginning of the year ₹20.00, NAV at the end ₹22.40, dividend (IDCW) paid during the year ₹0.80 per unit. Find the annual return.

Return = (NAVend − NAVbegin + Distribution) ÷ NAVbegin × 100 = (22.40 − 20.00 + 0.80) ÷ 20.00 × 100 = 3.20 ÷ 20 × 100 = 16%.

Expense Ratio and Loads

Expense ratio (Total Expense Ratio, TER): the yearly cost of running a scheme (fund management fee, RTA, custodian, audit, marketing, distributor commission) as a percentage of average daily net assets. It is deducted daily from NAV. SEBI fixes maximum TER slabs that fall as the scheme's size grows — check latest limits. Direct plans have lower TER than regular plans because no distributor commission is paid.

Example: average net assets ₹500 crore, total annual expenses ₹7.5 crore → TER = 7.5 ÷ 500 × 100 = 1.5%.

Loads: charges collected when units are bought or sold.

  • Entry load: charged at purchase — abolished by SEBI from August 2009, so units are now sold at NAV.
  • Exit load: charged at redemption if units are sold within a set period (e.g. 1% if redeemed within one year). Redemption price = NAV × (1 − exit load).

Example: NAV ₹15.25, exit load 1%; an investor redeems 2,000 units. Redemption price = 15.25 × 0.99 = ₹15.0975; amount received = 2,000 × 15.0975 = ₹30,195 (load deducted ₹305).

Risk–Return Analysis

Return is the gain on investment (NAV change plus distributions). Risk is the chance that the actual return differs from the expected return.

  • Standard deviation (σ): total risk — how much returns swing around the average.
  • Beta (β): systematic (market) risk — sensitivity of the fund to market movement. β = 1 moves with the market; β > 1 is aggressive; β < 1 is defensive.
  • Diversifiable (unsystematic) risk can be removed by diversification; market risk cannot.

Higher risk should bring higher expected return; risk-adjusted measures compare funds fairly.

Performance Measurement Tools: Sharpe Ratio, Treynor Ratio and Jensen's Alpha

  1. Sharpe ratio = (Rp − Rf) ÷ σp — excess return per unit of total risk. Used for a fund that is the investor's whole portfolio.
  2. Treynor ratio = (Rp − Rf) ÷ βp — excess return per unit of market risk. Used for a well-diversified fund.
  3. Jensen's alpha = Rp − [Rf + βp(Rm − Rf)] — the extra return over what CAPM expects. Positive alpha shows the manager's skill.

Where Rp = fund return, Rf = risk-free rate, Rm = market return. Higher value is better in all three.

Illustration 3: Risk-free rate 6%, market return 12%. Fund A: return 15%, σ 18%, β 1.2. Fund B: return 13%, σ 12%, β 0.8. Evaluate.

MeasureFund AFund B
Excess return (Rp − Rf)15 − 6 = 9%13 − 6 = 7%
Sharpe = excess ÷ σ9 ÷ 18 = 0.507 ÷ 12 = 0.58
Treynor = excess ÷ β9 ÷ 1.2 = 7.507 ÷ 0.8 = 8.75
CAPM expected return = 6 + β(12 − 6)6 + 7.2 = 13.2%6 + 4.8 = 10.8%
Jensen's alpha = Rp − expected15 − 13.2 = 1.8%13 − 10.8 = 2.2%

Conclusion: Fund A gives a higher raw return, but Fund B is better on all three risk-adjusted measures, so Fund B has performed better.

Benchmarking of Mutual Funds

A benchmark is a standard index against which a fund's performance is compared, e.g. Nifty 50 for a large-cap fund, CRISIL indices for debt funds. SEBI requires schemes to use the Total Return Index (TRI), which includes dividends, so comparison is fair. A fund that beats its benchmark after costs has generated value; a fund that keeps under-performing should be reviewed. Peer comparison with funds of the same category is also used.

Portfolio Disclosure Norms

  • Daily NAV on the AMC and AMFI websites.
  • Scheme portfolios disclosed monthly and half-yearly on the AMC and AMFI websites (check the latest SEBI timelines).
  • Monthly factsheet: AUM, holdings, sector allocation, TER, returns vs benchmark, risk ratios, riskometer.
  • Half-yearly financial results and annual report to unit holders.
  • Disclosure of changes in fund manager and of the riskometer every month.
Exam tip: In numericals, always write the formula first, then substitute, then give a one-line conclusion ("Fund B is better because ...").

Likely exam questions

  1. (Long, 8/16 marks) Explain the concept of NAV. From the following calculate NAV per unit: investments at market value ₹750 lakh, cash ₹30 lakh, receivables ₹20 lakh, accrued expenses ₹10 lakh, other liabilities ₹40 lakh, units outstanding 50 lakh.
  2. (Long, 8/16 marks) Explain Sharpe ratio, Treynor ratio and Jensen's alpha. Fund X earned 14% with σ 20% and β 1.1; risk-free rate is 5% and market return 11%. Calculate all three measures.
  3. (Short, 4 marks) What is expense ratio? Distinguish between direct and regular plans.
  4. (Short, 4 marks) Explain entry load and exit load.
  5. (Short, 4 marks) What is benchmarking of mutual funds?