Syllabus topics (RTMNU)
- Meaning, Definition, characteristics and types of companies
- Incorporation of a company
- Role and legal position of the promoter
- Lifting of the corporate veil
- Memorandum of Association
- Articles of Association
- Meaning, purpose and contents
- Alteration
- Doctrine of Ultra Vires and Indoor management
- Prospectus: Meaning, Types and misrepresentation in a prospectus
Company: Meaning, Definition and Characteristics
Definition (Sec 2(20), Companies Act, 2013): 'Company' means a company incorporated under this Act or under any previous company law. In simple words, a company is a voluntary association of persons, registered under law, having a separate legal entity, perpetual succession and limited liability.
- Separate legal entity β company is different from its members (Salomon v. Salomon & Co., 1897).
- Artificial person β created by law; acts through directors.
- Limited liability β members liable only up to unpaid amount on shares or guarantee.
- Perpetual succession β death or exit of members does not end the company.
- Common seal β optional since the 2015 amendment.
- Transferability of shares β freely transferable in a public company (Sec 44).
- Separation of ownership and management β shareholders own, Board manages.
- Can own property and sue or be sued in its own name.
Types of Companies
| Basis | Types |
|---|---|
| Incorporation | Statutory company (by special Act, e.g. LIC, SBI); Registered company (under Companies Act) |
| Liability | Limited by shares; Limited by guarantee; Unlimited company |
| Number of members | Private (2 to 200 members, restricts share transfer, Sec 2(68)); Public (minimum 7, Sec 2(71)); One Person Company β 1 member (Sec 2(62)) |
| Control | Holding and Subsidiary company (Sec 2(46), 2(87)) |
| Ownership | Government company β at least 51% paid-up capital held by Central/State Govt (Sec 2(45)); Non-government company |
| Others | Section 8 company (charitable, no dividend); Foreign company; Listed company; Small company; Producer company |
Incorporation of a Company
- Name reservation through the MCA portal (SPICe+ Part A / RUN).
- Digital Signature Certificate and DIN of proposed directors.
- Prepare MoA and AoA signed by subscribers.
- File SPICe+ form with the Registrar of Companies (ROC) along with MoA, AoA, declaration by a professional, subscribers' and directors' declarations, address proof of registered office, and fees (Sec 7).
- Certificate of Incorporation issued by ROC with Corporate Identity Number (CIN); PAN and TAN are issued with it. The company exists from the date in the certificate.
- Commencement of business (Sec 10A): a company with share capital must file a declaration within 180 days that every subscriber has paid for his shares.
Promoter: Role and Legal Position
Promoter (Sec 2(69)) is a person named as such in the prospectus or annual return, or who has control over the affairs of the company, or on whose advice the Board is accustomed to act.
- Role: conceives the idea, does feasibility study, gathers persons, arranges finance, chooses name, prepares MoA/AoA, appoints bankers and auditors, gets the company registered.
- Legal position: he is neither an agent nor a trustee of the company (it does not yet exist), but stands in a fiduciary position β must not make secret profit and must disclose all interests.
- Pre-incorporation contracts do not bind the company (Kelner v. Baxter); the promoter is personally liable. Under the Specific Relief Act, 1963, the company may adopt such contracts after incorporation if they are for its purposes.
- Liability: for misstatement in prospectus (Sec 34β35), for secret profit, and for fraud.
Lifting of the Corporate Veil
Normally the law treats the company as separate from its members (the 'corporate veil'). Lifting the veil means the court ignores the separate entity and looks at the real persons behind the company.
- Judicial grounds: fraud or improper conduct; sham or faΓ§ade company; evasion of tax; enemy character in war (Daimler Co. v. Continental Tyre, 1916); company acting as agent of its members; protection of public interest.
- Statutory grounds: furnishing false information at incorporation (Sec 7(7)); misstatement in prospectus (Sec 34β35); members falling below the minimum for more than six months (Sec 3A); fraudulent conduct of business during winding up (Sec 339).
Memorandum of Association (MoA)
The MoA is the charter of the company. It defines its constitution and the scope of its powers, and its relation with the outside world (Sec 2(56), Sec 4).
- Name clause β ends with 'Limited' or 'Private Limited'.
- Registered office clause β State in which office is located.
- Object clause β objects for which the company is formed.
- Liability clause β limited or unlimited.
- Capital clause β authorised capital and its division into shares.
- Subscription clause β names of subscribers and shares taken.
Articles of Association (AoA)
The AoA contains the internal rules and regulations for management of the company (Sec 2(5), Sec 5) β share issue, transfer, meetings, directors, dividends, borrowing. Model articles are given in Tables F to J of Schedule I (Table F for companies limited by shares).
| Basis | MoA | AoA |
|---|---|---|
| Nature | Charter; defines objects and powers | Internal rules of management |
| Relation | With outsiders | Between company and members |
| Status | Supreme document | Subordinate to MoA and Act |
| Alteration | Difficult; may need Govt/Tribunal approval | Easier; by special resolution |
| Acts beyond it | Void, cannot be ratified | Can be ratified by members |
Alteration of MoA and AoA
- MoA (Sec 13): special resolution required. Change of name needs Central Government approval; shifting registered office from one State to another needs Central Government (Regional Director) approval; change of objects of a company that raised money by prospectus needs newspaper notice and exit option to dissenting shareholders; capital clause altered under Sec 61.
- AoA (Sec 14): by special resolution; conversion of private into public company or vice versa (the latter needs Tribunal approval) is done by altering the AoA. Entrenchment provisions (Sec 5(3)) need stricter procedure.
Doctrine of Ultra Vires and Indoor Management
Ultra vires means 'beyond powers'. Any act of the company beyond the object clause of MoA is void and cannot be ratified even by all shareholders (Ashbury Railway Carriage Co. v. Riche, 1875). Directors are personally liable for such acts.
Indoor management (Royal British Bank v. Turquand, 1856): an outsider dealing with the company may assume that internal procedures have been properly followed. It protects outsiders against the doctrine of constructive notice. Exceptions: outsider knew of irregularity, was negligent or suspicious, or the document was forged.
Prospectus: Meaning, Types and Misrepresentation
Prospectus (Sec 2(70)) means any document described or issued as a prospectus, including a red herring prospectus, shelf prospectus, notice, circular or advertisement, inviting offers from the public for securities.
- Red herring prospectus (Sec 32) β lacks final price and quantity; used in book building.
- Shelf prospectus (Sec 31) β one prospectus for several issues over up to one year.
- Abridged prospectus (Sec 33) β short summary attached to application form.
- Deemed prospectus (Sec 25) β document by which securities are offered for sale to public through an issue house.
Misrepresentation: an untrue or misleading statement, or omission of a material fact, in a prospectus.
- Civil liability (Sec 35): directors, promoters, experts and persons authorising the issue must compensate investors who suffered loss; investors may also rescind the contract.
- Criminal liability (Sec 34): punishable as fraud under Sec 447.
- Defences: withdrawal of consent before issue; issue without his knowledge; reasonable belief that the statement was true.
Likely exam questions
- (Long, 8/16 marks) Define a company. Explain its characteristics and the different types of companies.
- (Long, 8/16 marks) What is a Memorandum of Association? Explain its contents and the procedure for its alteration. Distinguish between MoA and AoA.
- (Short, 4 marks) Explain the legal position of a promoter.
- (Short, 4 marks) Explain the doctrine of indoor management and its exceptions.
- (Short, 4 marks) What is a prospectus? Explain the liability for misrepresentation in a prospectus.